BestAgent founder Charlie Lamdin has defended the platform’s practice of using estate agency listings following complaints from agents on social media about copyright issues and lead generation costs.
Estate agents have raised concerns that BestAgent scrapes their property listings and then charges them for leads on enquiries for properties they are already marketing. The controversy has highlighted broader questions about data usage in the property sector, similar to concerns about transparency in proptech services.
Copyright and public data claims
In a statement, BestAgent argued that basic property information does not fall under copyright protection. “Basic facts about a property for sale aren’t anyone’s copyright, and it’s in the public interest that they can be shown publicly,” the statement said.
The platform claims it can legally display property addresses, prices, size and status information, alongside public records including HM Land Registry price paid data, Energy Performance Certificate register data, and local land charges information.
However, BestAgent acknowledged that agents can request removal of copyrighted material such as photographs. The company stated that such requests are currently handled manually, as automated content management features have not yet been built.
Agent benefits and lead generation
According to BestAgent, agents receive credit on every listing with links to their own websites. The platform offers free telephone enquiries from buyers, opportunities to connect with sellers through its ‘Find Your Agent’ service, and the ability to respond to or request moderation of public comments on their listings.
Lamdin told The Negotiator: “BestAgent solves the problem for serious sellers trying to identify the most suitable agent more easily. The advantage BestAgent gives to its listed agents is access to talk to more seller leads than they would otherwise get, at no cost unless instructed.”
If agents request copyright removal, BestAgent stated that listings would remain on the platform with public facts, exterior imagery, and public data records, but without the agent’s copyrighted content or ability to reply to comments.
Market implications
The dispute reflects ongoing tensions in the property industry over data ownership and lead generation costs. BestAgent positioned its service as a way to “level the playing field” for smaller agents competing for buyer access, though the reception from the agency community appears mixed.
The controversy comes as proptech platforms face scrutiny over service clarity and transparency. The outcome of this debate could have implications for how property portals and aggregation services operate in relation to agent-created content and listing data.