Nations approve guidelines for returning real estate stolen by the Nazis

Some 43 countries have agreed to back the first set of global guidelines for returning real estate when they were unveiled in Prague. Although they are nonbinding, the rules call for more transparency and speed in the processing of restitution claims for property stolen between 1933 and 1945. They also state that people claiming lost property should be given free access to all relevant local, regional and national archives.
 
‘We’ve made a major advance in providing belated justice to victims and their families,’ said Stuart Eizenstat, a special adviser to the US Secretary of State on Holocaust issues.
 
‘For the first time in 65 years nations have come together in Prague to provide a guideline and best practices for property confiscated and wrongly seized by the Nazis, fascists and their collaborators during the Holocaust era,’ he added.
 
It is estimated that before the Holocaust Jews owned property in Europe that was worth between $10 billion and $15 billion at the time. Most was taken and never returned or paid for, translating into a missing $115 billion to $175 billion in current prices.
 
Many Western European governments paid restitution for only a fraction of the stolen assets, while Eastern European countries in the Soviet bloc paid almost nothing at all.
 
Israel’s ambassador to the Czech Republic said he was pleased with the guidelines. ‘We’ve been negotiating for close to a year with some ups and downs and the final document practically addresses all our concerns,’ said Yaakov Levy.
 
But others are not so sure. ‘It would be revolutionary if governments really did adhere to these guidelines,’ said Tomas Jelinek, the former chairman of Prague’s Jewish community.
 
The rules are the product of yearlong negotiations kicked off at an international restitution conference in Prague last June. Delegates at that conference urged governments to make every effort to return former Jewish communal and religious property confiscated by Nazis, fascists and their collaborators, and recommended that states implement national programmes to address the issue of private buildings and land.
 
The guidelines also encourage states to eliminate hurdles for non-citizens seeking seized property and call for special funds to be set up in cases where there are no heirs to claim the stolen real estate.
 
If restitution of a particular property is not possible, ‘other acceptable solutions may include substituting property of equal value or paying genuinely fair and adequate compensation,’ the guidelines said.
 
Eizenstat stressed that much now depends on how countries implement the guidelines and stressed that time was of the essence. ‘We all have done not enough. There are 500,000 Holocaust survivors, roughly half of them living at or below the poverty level,’ he explained.
 
A conference to review progress is to take place in two years.