"The nature of demand for hotels is notoriously volatile, with factors impacting demand as varied as they are unpredictable," said Mr. Robert McIntosh, Executive Director, CBRE Hotels Asia. "Conversely, forecasting market supply is somewhat easier, despite some uncertainty in construction timeframes."
He believes that a greater choice of options tends to lead to an increase in demand for hotel rooms. "The result is an increase in total tourism expenditure compared to the position if the supply had remained static. This has positive implications for employment, demand for airline seats and expenditure in restaurants and other tourism attractions. However, extra supply does have a negative impact on the performance of existing hotels as occupancy levels and room rates tend to fall leading to decreased profitability."
The actual number of rooms to be added is greatest in Singapore. Although the increase in Hanoi is high in percentage terms it is not substantial in terms of the total number of rooms.
Singapore will experience the largest number of addition hotel rooms of the five cities, with nearly 10,000 four and five star rooms expected to open by the end of 2012. Assuming all projects proceed, this represents a 39 percent increase in supply over a relatively short period of time.
Hotel supply in Bangkok is expected to increase significantly, with over 6,000 four and five star hotels rooms set to enter the market by the end of 2012. This represents an increase of 26 percent bringing the total supply of four and five star hotels in the city to over 31,000 rooms.
"We believe three-star hotels in Bangkok will benefit from cost-cutting measures being employed by both businesses and individual travelers this year," according to Mr. Nabeel Hussain, Manager of CBRE Research in Thailand. "Branded budget hotels, such as the Ibis and All Seasons chains, are well-positioned to take advantage of this trend."
In Vietnam, the existing supply of four and five star hotels in key cities is relatively small compared to other markets. In Hanoi, new four and five star hotel supply is expected to total nearly 3,000 rooms representing an increase of 75 percent. Whilst this appears high, the market is growing from a relatively small base of just under 4,000 rooms (Singapore and Bangkok have over 30,000 four and five star rooms each). In Ho Chi Minh City, existing supply of four and five star hotel rooms is expected to increase by 38 percent to reach a total supply of over 7,000 rooms by the end of 2012.
The addition of new supply to these cities is essential in promoting further development of the tourism industry and to ensure capacity exists to accommodate future growth of visitor arrivals. This is particularly important in Ho Chi Minh City which currently suffers from a shortage of supply.
Finally, the hotel market in Kuala Lumpur will experience a modest increase in hotel rooms to the end of 2012, with the market set to increase by just ten percent to reach 20,400 hotel rooms. While average room rates and occupancy levels are less than those in Singapore, the relatively small increase in supply is unlikely to pose a significant challenge to the market in the next couple of years but it should help boost total tourism revenues.
The extent to which the additional supply will affect hotel performance will vary from market to market. "While additional supply combined with the current economic climate will likely lead to weaker occupancy levels in most markets in the short term, the increase in capacity will benefit some markets in the long term," Mr. McIntosh said.